a1b05858dabd7f67022d9a4585cb044b-us17

Greed Isn’t the Enemy: It’s an Underappreciated Edge

by | February 7th 2025 | SES, DEFUSE, OBSERVE

Key Points:

  1. Greed is a Neurobiological Signal, Not a Character Flaw: Your brain’s dopamine system drives reward-seeking behavior automatically. The problem isn’t greed itself; it’s greed operating without detection and regulation. Trained greed becomes market intelligence; untrained greed becomes a STRAY.
  2. Hidden Schemas Hijack Your Risk Decisions: Entitlement, Defectiveness, and Emotional Deprivation schemas distort how you perceive opportunity. Until you recognize which blueprint activates under pressure, greed controls you rather than serving you.
  3. Transform Greed Into Strategic Aggression: Use the SES framework to detect greed-driven state shifts early, unhook from urgent thoughts, and redirect impulse energy toward values-aligned execution. The goal isn’t elimination, it’s integration.

Greed has long been trading psychology’s favorite scapegoat. Blown accounts, overleveraged positions, and ignored stop losses are all blamed on this supposedly corrosive emotion. But here’s what the discipline-obsessed crowd gets wrong: greed isn’t the malfunction. Greed without regulation is a malfunction.

Much of conventional trading psychology was built by people without formal clinical training, and it shows. Their solution? Suppress greed. Control emotions. White-knuckle through the urge. This approach misunderstands how the brain actually works. Greed is wired into your neurobiology, linked to dopamine, survival instincts, and the pursuit of security. You can’t switch it off any more than you can decide not to feel hungry.

The real question isn’t whether you’ll experience greed,d you will, because you’re human and trading activities reward circuitry by design. The question is: what do you do with that signal when it arrives? Suppression doesn’t work. What works is detection, regulation, and redirection. When you can identify greed as it emerges and channel it through your trading framework rather than around it, greed transforms from liability to an edge.

The Neurobiology of Greed: Why Your Brain Wants More

Greed isn’t a moral failing; it’s a neurobiological event. When you spot a potential winner, your brain’s reward system activates before your conscious mind even registers what’s happening. This isn’t weakness; it’s evolution. The same circuitry that helped your ancestors survive by seeking resources now fires when you see price action that signals opportunity.

According to research published in PubMed, dopamine plays a central role in drive and reward systems, with the reward circuits capable of overwhelming prefrontal regulation during high-arousal states. Your dopamine system fuels the desire for reward, pushing you toward greater risk when opportunities appear attractive. Your prefrontal cortex tries to regulate these impulses, but under high-stress or high-reward conditions, it gets overridden. Your amygdala detects potential financial threat, making greed feel urgent and non-negotiable.

Research on reward prediction errors demonstrates that positive prediction errors, unexpected gains, increase subsequent risk-seeking behavior, while negative prediction errors create risk aversion. This means your risk tolerance isn’t stable; it shifts based on recent outcomes. A winning streak neurologically primes you for bigger bets. The greed you feel after three consecutive winners isn’t identical to baseline greed; it’s been amplified by your brain’s own learning mechanisms.

This is why “just follow the plan” fails precisely when following the plan matters most. The plan lives in your prefrontal cortex. Under a dopamine surge, the prefrontal cortex loses influence while subcortical reward systems take the wheel. You’re not thinking clearly because the part of your brain that thinks clearly has been temporarily demoted.

The Hidden Schemas Behind Greed

Here’s where it gets specific: not all traders experience greed the same way. Deeply ingrained belief patterns shape your personal relationship with greed, psychological blueprints formed early in life that continue running in the background, shaping how you perceive risk and opportunity.

Three Schemas That Weaponize Greed Against You

  • Entitlement: “I deserve this trade to work.” This belief pattern leads to overleveraging and ignoring stop losses because you feel the market owes you. When an Entitlement schema activates, position-sizing violations are rationalized as appropriate, given your superior read on the situation.
  • Defectiveness/Shame: “I’ll prove I’m not a failure by making this trade huge.” Greed here becomes compensation; each win temporarily patches a deeper wound of inadequacy. The problem: losses don’t just cost money, they confirm the shame, making the next greedy impulse even more urgent.
  • Emotional Deprivation: “This is my one shot to make real money.” This schema creates scarcity thinking every opportunity feels like it might be the last. The result is desperate, impulsive entries driven by fear of missing the only chance you’ll ever get.

Research on psychological flexibility demonstrates that deeply ingrained patterns lead to the continued use of the same avoidant strategies despite adverse consequences. These schemas don’t respond to logic because they weren’t created by logic. They were formed through emotional experience and continue operating below conscious awareness until something triggers them.

Until you recognize which schema activates your greed, willpower alone won’t help. You’re not fighting a single emotion; you’re fighting a whole network of automatic associations that learned to protect you decades ago and haven’t updated their strategy since.

“Between stimulus and response, there is a space. In that space is our power to choose our response. In our response lies our growth and our freedom.”  

Viktor Frankl

How Greed Becomes a STRAY Trigger

In the Sound Execution System, we call it what it is: a STRAY, a State-Triggered Reaction Against Yourself. These aren’t “mistakes” or “lack of discipline.” They’re predictable neurobiological events where emotional urgency overrides your stated values. Greed-driven STRAYs follow a specific mechanism:

  1. Opportunity appears (e.g., decisive move, winning streak, “can’t miss” setup)
  2. State shifts from regulated toward urgency building)
  3. Urgency intensifies (“I need to size up NOW” / “I have to catch this”)
  4. Schema activates (Entitlement, Defectiveness, or Emotional Deprivation)
  5. Urgency overrides values (body hijacks the plan)
  6. STRAY behavior occurs (position sizing violation, FOMO entry, rule violation)

The crucial distinction: this isn’t an execution error. Execution errors are technical mistakes made in a regulated state and are random, low-frequency, and easy to correct. STRAYs feel compulsive. They repeat predictably. They carry two costs: the money you lose (tangible, immediate) and the damage to your identity (cumulative, corrosive). That’s the real Tilt Tax each STRAY proves to yourself that you can’t be trusted, that you’re not who you say you are.

The Dark Side of Greed: When It Becomes Destructive

Unregulated greed doesn’t just hurt your P&L, it systematically erodes your trading identity. The most common patterns:

  • Position Sizing Violations: Small wins trigger greed; desperation triggers greed either way; you’re sizing beyond plan parameters. The Entitlement or Failure schema is running the show.
  • FOMO Entries: Price moves without you. Failure and Subjugation schemas activate. You chase after the setup criteria have passed because missing out feels like confirmation of inadequacy.
  • Holding Past Stops: “It’ll come back” thinking. Unrelenting Standards and Failure schemas make it intolerable to accept being wrong. You’d rather bleed out slowly than admit the greed-driven entry was flawed.
  • Rule Violations: “This time is different” rationalization. Entitlement tells you the rules apply to everyone except you in this specific situation.
  • Overtrading: Boredom and Emotional Deprivation team up. You need stimulation. Greed disguises itself as “just one more setup” until you’re taking trades outside any reasonable criteria.

Track your top 3 greed-driven STRAYs. Most traders have 2-3 dominant patterns that account for 80% of violations. Know yours by name.

Making Greed Work For You: The SES Approach

Since elimination isn’t possible, the goal becomes integration training, getting them to operate within your framework rather than against it.

Use Greed as a Performance Alert

Greed isn’t a red flag; it’s a yellow flag. It signals excitement, which can fuel legitimate opportunity recognition or schema-driven disaster. The difference depends entirely on your response. When greed appears, ask: “Am I greedy because I see a genuine edge that fits my criteria, or because I want quick gains that bypass my process?”

Build an Intraday Greed Management Routine

Before any trade where you notice elevated excitement, run a quick internal audit: What’s my current greed level on a 1-10 scale? Which schema might be activated right now? Does this trade fit my pre-planned criteria, or am I rationalizing? By treating greed as data rather than pathology, you shift from emotional trading to systematic execution.

Unhook From Greedy Thoughts

Greedy thoughts are only dangerous when you fuse with them, when “I have to make this trade” becomes a command rather than mental weather. The skill is creating space between the thought and the action:

  • Name it: “I notice I’m having the thought that this trade will change everything.”
  • Say it in a ridiculous voice. Seriously. It breaks the spell by revealing the thought as just noise, not instruction.
  • Write it down and read it back. Externalizing the thought creates distance between you and the urgency.

SES Framework Connections

  1. DETECT: Trade your nervous system before trading the market. Greed has physical signatures, such as an elevated heart rate, forward lean, and racing thoughts that appear before the trade decision crystallizes. Catch Yellow Zone escalation early, before dopamine surge pushes you into Red Zone, where values go offline.
  2. DIRECT: Steer by values, not impulses. When greed activates, willpower collapses. What survives? Operational values. What kind of trader are you building? What does integrity look like at your desk? These identity anchors hold when urgency screams otherwise.
  3. DEFUSE: Cut the wire between thought and action. Greed-driven thoughts arrive with commanding urgency. The skill isn’t eliminating them it’s changing your relationship to them. Notice “I have to size up” as a thought, not a directive. Create the gap between trigger and trade.
  4. OBSERVE: Move to the Watchtower. In the Trenches, you’re inside the greed reacting from it, unable to see the pattern. From the Watchtower, you observe the pull toward action without surrendering to it. This is what separates traders who recognize greed activation from traders who discover it only in their P&L.
  5. INTEGRATE: Turn error into data. When greed drives a STRAY, punishment and shame erase the information you need to improve. Integration means processing the slip without identity damage: What triggered this? What was the state? What schema activated? The goal is to prevent one slip from becoming a cascade.

Actionable Strategies

  1. Build a Greed Detection Protocol: Before each session, note your baseline state. During trading, track when excitement spikes beyond baseline. Log the specific thoughts that accompany greed activation. Over time, you’ll recognize your personal early warning signatures.
  2. Create a Greed-Specific Pause Ritual: When you detect greed activation, implement a 90-second pause before any sizing decision. Use that time to run the audit: State level? Schema activated? Criteria fit? This forces the prefrontal cortex back online before action.
  3. Practice Willingness With Discomfort: Greed often masks fear of missing out, inadequacy, and scarcity. Practice sitting with the discomfort of not acting on greed without trying to make it go away. The impulse doesn’t need to feel resolved before you can execute with discipline.
  4. Anchor to Operational Values: Write down three trading values that matter more than any single trade. When greed activates, ask: “Which choice aligns with who I’m building myself to be?” This redirects energy from outcome-desperate to process-committed.
  5. Review Without Judgment: After any greed-driven trade, conduct a post-trade review focused on the mechanism rather than the outcome. What was the state transition? What schema was activated? What would earlier detection have changed? Learning replaces punishment.

Act Accordingly

Greed is inevitable in trading. It will arrive because your brain is wired to seek reward, and trading constantly activates that circuitry. The traders who fail either ignore their greed until it’s running the show or spend all their energy trying to suppress something that can’t be suppressed.

The traders who win? They recognize greed as a signal, not an enemy. They detect it early, understand which schema is amplifying it, unhook from the commanding urgency, and redirect that energy through their framework. They don’t fight greed; they integrate it.

By recognizing when greed arises, why it triggers you specifically, and how to pivot toward disciplined execution, you transform emotional reactivity into strategic advantage.

Greed is a tool. Use it.

Sean Sawyer, MS

Psychotherapist | Trader

Sean Sawyer has been a psychotherapist since 2003 and a full-time trader since 2018. Sean helps traders prevent tilt & repeat the same mistakes by rewiring the brain patterns that fail them under pressure.